“I’ve got bad news, kids. You’re terrible people.”
That wasn’t my exact opener for my Wednesday night kid’s class at church, but it might as well have been. We’ve been going through Old Testament history for a few months and are currently working through the judges material. My synopsis of the book of Judges was received just fine by the three children in my class for 4-6 year olds, but when I asked for examples of doing what is right in our own eyes, the room was oddly quiet.
Admittedly, Judges is a tricky book to explain to small children. I focused on the cycle of sin that we see on repeat throughout the book: Israel sins, God sends judgment, the people cry out to God, God relents and forgives, but then Israel sins again, and the cycle repeats in a downward spiral. I even cut up a paper plate to demonstrate what a downward spiral looks like, so to speak. But, when I began talking about the cycle of sin in our own lives and the power of the gospel to break the cycle of sin, I received a few quizzical looks.
“What’s sin?” one little boy* asked me (in his defense, he doesn’t attend church often). Below is the dialogue that followed.
“Sin is any disobedience toward God,” I replied. “So, for example, when you disobey your mom, you’re also disobeying God because He has put your mom in charge of you.” I further explained that if we wanted to be reconciled to God (or, “friends” with God so the youngest in my bunch could understand), we need to believe that Jesus paid for our sin at the cross and then we must follow Him and live our lives like He did.
“Oh,” the little boy responded. “Well, I don’t do any of that sin.”
I tried not to smile. “You know what, buddy, I’m afraid you do. We all do.”
The look on his face was not one of amusement. “Not me. I don’t ever do anything wrong.”
I squelched a laugh. “Can you think of a time when you did something selfish or unkind?”
“Nope.”
I pressed him further. “So you’re telling me that every single time your mom has ever told you to do something, you have always immediately jumped up, said ‘yes ma’am!’ and obeyed perfectly?”
“Yep.”
I gently replied,”You know what, kiddo, I’m not trying to hurt your feelings, but I don’t believe you. You know why? Because the Bible tells us that every single person who has ever lived has sinned except for Jesus.”
He continued to shake his head in disagreement.
“Let me give you an example. So, it’s hard for me to admit this to you guys, but sometimes I get impatient with my kids and I yell at them. Does that seem kind?” All three kids shook their heads no. “When I do that, I’m not doing what’s right in God’s eyes, and it’s sin for me to be unkind to my children. I’m disobeying God by not loving my children and showing them kindness. Does that make sense?” All three nodded. Great, I’m the only sinner in the room and they all know it.
“Now can you give me an example of a way maybe you have done what is right in your own eyes?” (I wasn’t looking for a confession but rather trying to help them picture what sin against God looks like in their context.)
Mr. Innocent continued shaking his head no, but the girl sitting across from me shyly raised a hand.
“Sometimes my mom tells me to do stuff, but…(the little girl turned her head to the side and whispered into her shoulder), sometimes I don’t do it.”
“That’s a good example!” I encouraged her. “We don’t always want to do what our parents tell us, so we disobey–”
“I said sometimes!” the little girl interjected. “I disobey just sometimes.”
“Well…okay.” I was losing this battle. I looked to the last little member of my class. “Anything to add?”
He looked at me with big eyes and absolutely zero response.
“Pleading the fifth, I see.”
We Must Be Devastated by the Bad News.
To be honest, I didn’t think I’d meet any disagreement on human depravity in my class that night. But the resistance I encountered is just a more frank display of what I see in most adults. Perhaps it seems like I was badgering the kids in my class, but I love them each and was as gentle as possible while also trying to expose what we all have difficulty admitting: we are bad people at heart. I’m not addressing the value of our lives. This is not an imago dei discussion. I’m talking about the curse of sin that has run through the roots of every family tree since Eden. R.C. Sproul said it this way, “The doctrine of original sin teaches that people sin because we are sinners. It’s not that we are sinners because we sin, but rather, we sin because we are sinners; that is, since the fall of man, we have inherited a corrupted condition of sinfulness. We now have a sin nature.” (source)
It is counter-cultural and some would say damaging to teach this to our kids, but the good news of the gospel isn’t good news at all if we’re pretty good people at heart. Until we understand that we’re not “pretty good” at heart, we cannot understand the gravity of Jesus’ redemptive work at the cross. Pretty good people don’t need a savior and we should consider Jesus’ sacrifice at the cross wasteful if we all believe we’re not that bad. The truth is, even sometimes disobedience (only sometimes!) is still a wedge between our dark hearts and our holy God. Even one sin is enough to drive us from the presence of God; just ask Adam and Eve.
Coming to terms with our sinfulness and our bent toward disobedience and dissatisfaction in God is the first step to believing the gospel. The gospel will not be good news to us until we are first devastated by the bad news.
The gospel will not be good news to us until we are first devastated by the bad news. Share on XThe Bad News Makes Way for the Good News.
I explained to my little class that they wouldn’t really be able to love Jesus until they realized how much they needed Him. Agreeing with God that we are a sinful people is the impetus for new birth. It’s something a child can believe and own, but it’s difficult at every stage to admit: I am not good. And further, I cannot make myself good.
The Bible tells us that no one seeks after God and that there is in fact none who are righteous (Ps. 14:1, Rom. 3:10-11). The Law given in the Old Testament exposed the desperation of God’s people for a redeemer. They could not obey perfectly, nor could they rescue themselves. Case in point: Judges was a disastrous, dark period of biblical history wherein people only did what they desired. They were slaves to their flesh. The apostle Paul termed our crooked human nature a “body of death” (Rom. 7:24). He’s not being extreme.
Acknowledging our helpless sinfulness is a bitter pill to swallow, but swallow it we must in order to see the glory of the provision made for us at Calvary. The God we cannot reach in our state of despair reached out to us by sending Jesus as a propitiation for our sin. In a scandalous exchange, Jesus became our sin, and we get to wear His righteousness. Only repentance and faith in and through Christ can break the power of our sin cycle and dress us in the purity of Christ. In that exchange we move from sinner to saint. We’re not sinless, not yet. But one day we most certainly will be.
We Need to Hear the Bad News and the Good News.
I was a child when I first believed the gospel. I thought up until that point that I was a good kid and that God probably really liked me a lot because I didn’t disobey my parents very much. I thrived on being “the good kid.” Do you see it? Though outwardly obedient, my heart was dark and dead. Pride snaked its way through my veins hissing half truths that seemed probable: I’m not that bad. I’m not like that person over there. God probably even loves me more because I’m pretty good.
But through the many gospel presentations given by my parents, my pastors, my Sunday school teachers, my Wednesday night class teachers–I gradually became aware of my sinfulness. It was crushing to understand that I wasn’t as good as I thought I was. But beneath the crushing weight of sin is where we hear the Savior say, “My burden is light. Believe in God, believe also in Me.”
I’m parenting two children myself, and it never feels good to tell my boys that they need new hearts. It goes against the grain of our self-esteem boosting, identity-affirming culture. Though I affirm my love for my children, their uniqueness and giftedness, their imago dei, I am doing them no favors to tell them they are innocent human beings who are pretty good at heart. And yet, giving them the bad news is quickly followed by the very best news: Jesus can make you new!
*No names have been used in order to protect the guilty, the sometimes guilty, and the never guilty.
Photo by Varshesh Joshi on Unsplash
Glenna Marshall is married to her pastor, William, and lives in rural Southeast Missouri where she tries and fails to keep up with her two energetic sons. She is the author of The Promise is His Presence (P&R) and Everyday Faithfulness (Crossway), and Memorizing Scripture (Moody). Connect with her on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.