“You don’t get to know why. You just need to trust me.”
I cannot count how many times this phrase has left my mouth over the last few weeks. I have a three-year-old, and nearly every question out of his mouth these days is “why?”
I only answer my son’s why questions about half the time, to be honest. Sometimes I don’t want to answer him because the why is a reflex more than a sincere question Sometimes I don’t know the answer. Sometimes there’s no time for it. He doesn’t need to know why I expect obedience when there’s imminent danger. There’s no time to explain broken bones, head injuries, and death when I’m calling for him to come away from the street. He doesn’t get to know why all the time, but he does need to trust me and obey.
We Think We Need a Why
Three Octobers ago, I was entangled in a legal battle for this very child when his adoption fell apart in a way we never saw coming. During that same October, I was finally given a name for the mysterious disease that crippled me with pain. I was sick, and I was petrified of losing a child I’d quickly loved but held with both a clenched fist and a loose grip. That was a hard fall.
Two Octobers ago, I spent many days next to my mom’s side while she recovered from brain surgery. I remember one October Sunday when she was feeling well enough to sit on her back porch where we watched the squirrels empty her bird feeder. We drank spiced tea, and I quietly worried if the mother I’d had up until that point would come back to me completely. She did, eventually. But that that was also a hard fall.
Last October, I holed up in cabin in the woods during one weekend and wrote much of the book that comes out next year. I picked apart the ways God was with me in the middle of the previous two Octobers, and all the ones prior when I yearned for babies and battled a silent disease. In all those Octobers, I couldn’t pin down a reason for any of the shadows of fall or why I had to walk through the valleys that came with the turning leaves.
I didn’t know what God was doing in any of my suffering or in the quiet days of waiting with longings piercing my heart. I thought He was just being slow to answer my prayers. Or maybe He was ignoring me. Sometimes you just don’t get to know why the waiting is long and the prayers seem unanswered.
When I untangle my desire to understand why we go through hard things, what’s beneath it is a desire for a guaranteed positive outcome. But does knowing all will end well this side of heaven really require me to trust God? Looking back at the Octobers of my past, I can now see some of the ways He was working for my good and teaching me to trust Him. But not knowing why at the time wrought a deeper kind of trust than would have grown if I’d known exactly what the future held. Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. Is it really trusting God to be sovereign and good if you demand to know every strand of His reasoning? We might think solace is found in having a concrete answer to our why, but real solace comes in knowing God can be trusted.
We might think solace is found in having a concrete answer to our why, but real solace comes in knowing God can be trusted. Share on XNot Why, But Who
In all those old Octobers, I thought of Job a lot. He wasn’t privy to the discussion between God and Satan. He didn’t know he was being sifted or that God was certain of his perseverance. When he voiced his why to God, God’s answer wasn’t a why but who. The study of God’s character we’re given in the story of Job is perhaps the real gift of the book. Job wanted to know–Was it his sin? Was God set against him? Was it something Job forgot to do? Why all this suffering and loss? God didn’t give Job the answer Job might have thought would satisfy him. But God gave Job the answer he needed. The answer was God himself. Not why, but who.
Job questioned God in a way we can surely relate to. “I will say to God: ‘Do not declare me guilty! Let me know why You prosecute me,’” (Job 10:2). But God answered with descriptions of how He created everything and sovereignly holds it all together without any help from Job or his friends. “Will the one who contends with the Almighty correct Him? Let him who argues with God give an answer…Would you really challenge My justice? Would you declare Me guilty to justify yourself? Do you have an arm like God’s? Can you thunder with a voice like His?” (Job 40:2, 8-9) Rather than tell Job why he was suffering, God showed Job the scope of His power in creating the world and sustaining it.
It’s odd to answer why with who, but God showed Job He could be trusted, blindly trusted. We want to know why God does what He does or why He seems silent when we demand an answer. We think knowing every nuanced train of His thought will bring us comfort for the valleys of shadow we walk through. But more than knowing why, we can find comfort in who He is and what He has done to sustain us.
Those who belong to Christ are safe in His hands (see John 10). Though we may walk through pain, heartache, physical suffering—even death—our souls are eternally safe in Christ. He suffered God’s wrath in our place so that we can be reconciled to God and have eternity with Him. When Jesus was resurrected, He guaranteed our resurrection. If God allows suffering, we can trust that the sovereign, good God who did not spare His own Son for us will sustain us when we can’t see how He’ll do it.
“He did not even spare His own Son but offered Him up for us all; how will He not also with Him grant us everything?” (Rom. 8:32)
Know The Who
You may not know what’s going on in your hard days right now–why God does what He does or doesn’t do what you want Him to do. You may not know until next October or ten Octobers from now. Or maybe you won’t know until your feet are standing in the new creation where time isn’t measured by Octobers.
You don’t have to know why God works the way He does or doesn’t. You just have to know Him. Look to the Word and all the ways He is revealed as sovereign, good, just, and wise. I mean that literally—take a pen and a notebook and write down every statement or intimation about God. Start with Job, or Isaiah, or Psalms, or John, or Colossians. Whatever Scripture says about God’s character, write it down and meditate on it until you believe it. Setting your heart on His faithfulness will settle our anxiousness, gazing on His goodness will calm your fears, studying His presence will comfort your loneliness.
Eventually, you’ll see that even when you don’t know why you’re enduring suffering or uncertainty, you can trust God with your life. Knowing Him is enough to endure.
Photo by Ken Treloar on Unsplash
Glenna Marshall is married to her pastor, William, and lives in rural Southeast Missouri where she tries and fails to keep up with her two energetic sons. She is the author of The Promise is His Presence (P&R) and Everyday Faithfulness (Crossway), and Memorizing Scripture (Moody). Connect with her on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.